Review: The One and Only Vivian Stone by Melissa O'Connor

The One and Only Vivian Stone

by Melissa O'Connor

Release Date: July 22, 2025

2025 Gallery Books

Ebook ARC; 368 Pages

ISBN; 978-1668074831

ASIN: B0DHV4MQJS

Audiobook: B0DYQDZGXD

Genre: Fiction / Historical 

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

4 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

After her grandmother’s death, thirty-something Margot DuBois prepares to sell the house quickly so she can go back to her predictable life in Santa Barbara. But while cleaning out the attic, she comes across eight unlabeled cassette tapes. Unable to use the damaged tape player, she calls in a favor from Leo—her first love and first epic heartbreak—and they strike a deal: he’ll fix the player if he can hear what’s on the tapes. When they manage to listen, the two are shocked to hear the voice of comedic legend Vivian Stone. Why did she record these tapes and how did Margot’s grandmother get them?

Between listening to Vivian recount everything from her forbidden love for Hollywood’s leading actor, to working under a misogynistic exec, to her chemistry with her costar-turned-husband on TV, Margot and Leo fall down a memory lane of their own. Margot is inspired by Vivian’s tenacity and courage to keep fighting for the life she wants, but everything changes when Vivian reveals a secret from her past in this moving exploration of how it’s never too late to start over. 

 

My Thoughts

The One and Only Vivian Stone is one of those books that surprised me by the emotional impact it had on me while I was reading. I wasn't expecting to become as involved in Vivian's life as I did and I really rooted for her as her story unfolded. I'm still not a fan of the dual-timelines and I personally did not like Margot's story in the present, but I thoroughly enjoyed Vivian's story and wanted to know more after the tapes concluded.  

 

The strength of this book for me was definitely Vivian's character development. She went from a naive ingenue to someone who realized her worth in comedic acting, but needed to learn her strengths and weaknesses as she took on more demanding acting roles. I loved how she really wanted to be a dramatic actress and went through the withdrawal of realizing she just wasn't capable of pulling off roles like that only to realize her worth as a comedic actress and how those roles were just as important. 

 

Vivian was a remarkably complex person who struggled with the ambitious side to her personality with the woman who wanted love and a family. Like I've mentioned, she was ambitious and strong-willed, but she was also vulnerable and quite loyal to her friends and family. I don't even think I realized how skillfully the author created a more polished mature version of Vivian as she became successful in Hollywood from the naive woman in her earlier years.  I was also impressed with the way Vivian's romantic relationships were developed as we saw one that was more shallow in nature and one that was more in-depth. Both relationships were well-done and I appreciated how a person can love two people in a different way, one from a place of healing and one from a place of friendship.  When one became toxic, it was still done with respect and understanding, coming from a traumatic place in Vivian's past. 

 

I wasn't overly impressed with Margot's character arc, but it could simply be there was not enough time given to her to really develop her character the way Vivian's was developed. I just did not emphasize with her situation and I found her defensive all of the time.  

 

The plot wound itself around the characters and their development, but it was quite deceptive in nature. It dealt with a lot of serious themes such as sexual harassment in Hollywood, the misogyny that existed, and the control over actors' lives. The meticulous research that went into this book highlighted the difficulty of actors when they were bound to contracts with studios and literally had no personal rights and were told who to date and if they could even have children. It even delves into the topic of the drug abuse and how the actors were forced to take uppers/downers, diet pills, etc...Women's lack of control as well as lack of contribution to screen writing and directing was also a big theme running through the book. 

 

Verdict

The One and Only Vivian Stone was a very surprising and fascinating book. I think the author tried to honour the glamour of Hollywood, but also wanted to highlight the difficulties of being a star during the 1950s and how much the glamour actually hid. Actors didn't have freedom to do their own thing and were always afraid of losing their contracts, and the complexities of navigating the harassment during this time period for women were done delicately, but didn't downplay the seriousness of what was happening.  I did think the end of the story was a bit disappointing however, and didn't quite fit with the rest of the story. I also thought Margot's story felt more like something the author threw in as a way to tell Vivian's story; therefore, I do feel like this book didn't really need the dual timeline.