Review: The Killer Question by Janice Hallett

The Killer Question

by Janice Hallett

Release Date: September 4, 2025

2025 Atria Books

Ebook ARC; 448 Pages

ISBN: 978-1668083536

ASIN: B0DV6L843Z

Audiobook: B0F4ZH95Y2

Genre: Fiction / Mystery

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

3 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

Sue and Mal Eastwood run an isolated rural pub called The Case is Altered where a weekly trivia game has revived its flagging fortunes—that is, until a body is found in the nearby river. Soon after, a mysterious new team arrives and shakes up the diverse field of regulars by scoring top marks in every round...every week.

Meanwhile, Sue and Mal have a secret of their own. Before arriving here, they were caught up in a secret police operation which meant they had to leave town—and whatever happened back then seems to have finally caught up with them.

Five years later, the pub lies derelict, and their nephew Dominic is determined to make a documentary about their story. What happened at this unassuming pub? And can a single question really kill?

 

My Thoughts

The Killer Question is one of those books for which I had high hopes as I had enjoyed previous books by this author and relished another book that would have those twists and turns for which she is known. The twists and turns were definitely there, but I do have to say that I thought the book was overly long and as a result, the usual tension was lacking because there was so much lag time. 

 

The mystery itself was quite interesting, and as I mentioned, full of twists and turns. The format was unique, told through text messages and emails, a format for which this author is known, and it did keep me guessing as to what was going on. While I did figure out a few things, there was definitely one big curveball that I didn't see coming, and I was thrilled when that happened, and yes, shocked. And while all the elements of the plot did come together nicely in the end, unfortunately, the format for me, while unique and interesting, did lag at times with unnecessary things and I felt like the tension of the overall story was affected. The repetition did get to me at times. 

 

I also thought the character development was one-dimensional in this book and didn't really connect to any of the characters. Yes, there were a lot of them, but they were quite easy to sort out and I do have to commend the author for trying to give them individual personalities, but I don't think it quite worked. That being said however, I did appreciate how committed the people were to their quizzing nights and the preparation they would have put into learning information and facts; to be fair, I am quite competitive when I play these games as well so I get the passion and the obsession and the work that goes into these nights.  However, most of the characters seemed to have similar personalities and I really wasn't rooting for any of them, nor was I empathizing with any of them, something that left me disconnected to what was happening. So, when the big 'thing' happened, while I was shocked, it was more relief that something finally happened so get things moving along because it was kind of dragging for the first quarter of the book. And don't even get me started on the character Fiona and the stereotyping that happened with her character because of her age. 

 

Verdict

The Killer Question had an interesting format, but I also felt this format hindered the book at the same time. The pacing was a huge issue for me as it felt like nothing happened for the first quarter of the book, and then when the first twist happened, things didn't really progress from that point for quite a while. The last quarter of the books had some shocking twists and turns, and while I was enjoying the story, I was also ready to be done. It's too bad as I really enjoyed a couple of this author's previous novels, but this one was not my favourite. However, overall, this one was still enjoyable, I did like the format, and when the twists did come, they were good. I just wish the pacing and the character development were as good as the twists. 

 

 

 

 

 

Review: Broken Dolls by Ally Malinenko

Broken Dolls

by Ally Malinenko

Release Date: September 30, 2025

2025 HarperCollins

Ebook ARC; 272 Pages

ISBN: 978-0063355194

ASIN:  ‎ B0DRVSSBBV

Audiobook: B0DSCHZ64L

Genre: Fiction / Juvenile Fiction / Horror

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

5 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

One. Two. Three. Are you ready to play?

Ever since Kaye's grandfather died, she's been obsessed with counting the steps to her bedroom, the dolls on her sister's bed, even the threads on her favorite blanket. It's arithmomania, and with the selective mutism that sometimes prevents her from speaking, she literally can't find the words to talk about how she feels now that Grampa is gone. When they take the summer to clean out and renovate his old house, Kaye finds herself counting the days.

That is, until her younger sister, Holly, starts finding dolls. She finds them buried in the backyard, stuffed in the walls, crammed into the closets. From the first one, Kaye knows they aren't like normal dolls. They smile at her like they know something, and sometimes their eyes open and close on their own. Kaye hears her sister talking to them constantly—and she swears she's heard the dolls whispering back.

 

My Thoughts

Broken Dolls grabbed my attention right from the first pages and never really let up, to the point where I read it in one sitting because I didn't want to stop reading it.  It had the perfect blend of atmosphere, creepy elements, disturbing situations, and the thematic elements of grief running through all of this. Losing a close family member can be traumatizing and to read about it through the eyes of an 11 year old is very impactful. I thought this was a perfect blend of character and plot development for a juvenile fiction book.

 

Kaye is suffering with arithmomania, also known as counting OCD, often driven by anxiety and a desire to avoid anything catastrophic or disturbing. On top of this, she has also developed selective mutism that prevents her from speaking as she grapples with grief from her grandfather's death. Knowing how worried this makes her mother and her uncle, she struggles with her emotions by trying to placate them which makes the situation almost worse at times. I really connected with Kaye and felt very empathetic to what she was going through. With my own kids losing their grandfather at the same age, I definitely understood the difficulties from both Kaye's and her mother's point of view. She was a very well-developed character and I enjoyed her journey throughout the book. I also thought the other characters had their own personalities, but they were not as developed as Kaye, not that they needed to be, not for this story.

 

I thought the book had the perfect blend of horror for a juvenile fiction book. I mean, we are talking about dolls. Ugly dolls, Dolls that get up and move. Dolls that talk. That would be enough to send me out the door, thank you very much.  Kaye had more strength than I would have had in the same situation because the moment that doll started moving, well, back in the ground it would have gone.  There are no really big jump scares in this book, but it definitely has a creepy element running throughout it, one that doesn't let up throughout the entire book. I loved how the author kept the tension at a pretty high level and kept me invested. There are twists and turns and discoveries to be made, something I would have loved as a kid. I also thought the author did a fantastic job of weaving the element of grief throughout the story and allowed Kaye to grieve and find her own path. That was so well done.

 

Verdict

Broken Dolls is a great book for anyone who loves the terrifying doll trope, even if the book was written with the juvenile audience in mind. The author does a great job of building tension in this book and I loved the relationship between Holly and Kaye. Maybe I am a bit biased when it comes to this book as I read a lot of horror and not a lot of things bother me, but dolls will send me packing, fast.  I definitely recommend this book as it has a main character to whom you can relate and the author did a great job at building the tension without making it too scary for those younger readers.  

 

Review: Debbie Gibson: The Message in my Music by Debbie Gibson

Eternally Electric: The Message in My Music

by Debbie Gibson 

Release Date: September 9, 2025

2025 Gallery Books

Ebook ARC; 320 Pages

ISBN: 978-1668056769

ASIN:  ‎ B0DHY38Q9F

Audiobook: B0DWP6VM3T

Genre: Non-Fiction / Biography

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

3.5 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

Debbie Gibson was just sixteen when she released her multi-platinum debut album Out of the Blue and recorded “Foolish Beat” in 1988, making her the youngest person to ever write, produce, and perform a Billboard Hot 100 chart-topper.

A child actress who became the original pop princess, Debbie had full creative control over her music and, when that no longer aligned with a transitioning arts scene, she went on to star in Broadway’s Les Misérables, Beauty and the Beast, and Cabaret, as well as in the London production of Grease. Yet, for all the accolades and achievements, her success came at a high price.

Anxiety, depression, financial struggles, illness—Debbie writes candidly about these and other challenges, and how she ultimately redesigned her life to overcome them.

 

My Thoughts

Eternally Electric: The Message in my Music was a very candid biography by Debbie Gibson on her life growing up as a pop superstar. I have a really difficult time evaluating books like this, so I will mention that my rating focuses on organization, readability, and pacing of the book, not what the artist chooses to reveal or not reveal in their book as that is their choice.  Pretty much any girl who grew up in the 80's would be familiar with both Debbie Gibson and Tiffany as these two women were huge role models for young girls during this time period when young pop singers weren't really a thing.  

 

The memoir focuses on Debbie's rise to fame as a young artist in a cut-throat business, her struggles when her albums didn't perform as well as hoped, her venture into Broadway, her personal struggles with her health including anxiety and panic attacks as well as exhaustion, and her resilience as she re-discovers her love for writing and composing music. At its heart, its a book about self-discovery and perseverance and hope. 

 

As a kid, I definitely didn't realize how much freedom Debbie Gibson was given when making her first couple of albums. As a song-writer, producer, and artist for the albums, she certainly had a lot of creative control over them and it was a shame the music company didn't allow her the same freedom later in her career as she had certainly proven she had what it took to be successful. This is the time period when you would have to sit by the radio to record songs if you weren't able to purchase the tapes, and MTV and Much Music were just getting off the ground, so it was a different time period. You had to wait for gossip about your stars in your favourite magazines and we didn't know as much about the stars as we do today.

 

I always appreciate how open people are in their biographies and how willing they are to share their struggles with others as I am not sure I could do the same. Debbie Gibson was quite frank when sharing her difficulties with her personal relationships, her financial struggles, and the struggles with her health. I have three autoimmune diseases, so I understand how difficult it would have been when she was trying to get a diagnosis for Lyme's Disease and wondering what was going on with her and how frustrating that would have been.  When you don't know what is happening, having a diagnosis is almost a relief in comparison, even if it's not what you want. I also wonder how much having her mother as a manager created additional pressure to keep going, and going, and going, as she mentions in passing a couple of times how she is responsible for their lifestyles and their salaries, so was this too much pressure for her? While she talks highly about her mother, there are some things that make me question if her mother was the best person to be her manager. 

 

With all that being said, I did feel like the book was somewhat gossipy at times and sometimes reverted to name-dropping instead of explaining. It's not that the gossipy thing is bad as it was interesting, but a little more clarification on certain events rather than the gossip would have been nice. I did enjoy the personal anecdotes and having been a fan of NKOTB, it was interesting to hear what they have been up to these past couple of years. I also really enjoyed learning about Debbie Gibson's time on Broadway as I didn't really know a lot about that so I found it fascinating. 

 

Verdict

Eternally Electric was a book that took me back to the 80s and my high school years, and I found it nostalgic and inspiring. Her authenticity and resilience really struck a chord with me and I enjoyed reading about her life and the experiences she had as a singer, producer, composer. And boy, is she one talented lady!!! Even if you weren't a fan, I would still recommend this book to anyone who is looking for a book that is inspiring and heartfelt.  

 

Review: Carnival of Lies by D.V. Bishop

Carnival of Lies (Cesare Aldo, #5)

by D.V. Bishop

Release Date: August 26, 2025

2025 MacMillan UK

Ebook ARC; 400 Pages

ISBN: 978-1035041947

ASIN: B0DH4KR1Z9

Audiobook: B0DH99DVH2

Genre: Fiction / Historical / Mystery

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

4 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

Venice. Winter, 1539. When Cesare Aldo learns of a conspiracy to assassinate Duke Cosimo de’ Medici, he is hired to protect the ruler of Florence. With his life, if necessary. The deadly attack which follows leads to bodies, bloodshed – and something far more dangerous.

Those behind the plot obtain a journal of the duke’s, containing explosive secrets that – in the wrong hands – could destroy all of Florence. Aldo must hunt down those responsible and reclaim the journal, or face banishment from the city and everyone he loves. 

The trail leads him towards the one place Aldo has sworn to never return, a city of masks and lies where he has no allies and far too many enemies, Venice. The fate of a dynasty rests on his shoulders, if he can make it out alive . . .

 

My Thoughts

Carnival of Lies is the fifth entry in the Cesare Aldo historical mystery series, and while this was a great read, I don't think it was my favourite of the series to this point. It's not that it wasn't good as it definitely was, but that it seemed to lack the tension that existed in the previous books where I didn't know what was going to happen to Aldo and worried about him constantly. In this one, I just felt like he wasn't in the same amount of danger. Maybe it was the way it was written, but for the first time I found the twists and turns to be more predictable than usual and easily figured out what was happening.

 

I must start by saying that this book is somewhat different than the previous four installments in that Aldo was sort of inadvertently caught in the middle of something between Florence and Venice due to some intrigue that happened in the previous book. This intrigue carried into this book and while it was definitely a separate plot and very satisfying on its own, it was not Aldo simply investigating a murder or series of murders. A lot of the political stuff that was building in previous books has now reared its ugly head and Aldo can't escape its claws. There are twists and turns aplenty, a lot of intrigue, a female spy to deal with, and even the return of an old lover in Aldo's life. While there was a murder, it was a very insignificant part of the book while the author focused on the bigger political issues happening during this time period. I did find all of this very intriguing as I love politics and I love history having taught it for thirty plus years, but I did feel that it did diminish the overall tension to the plot as I never really felt like Aldo was in danger and could easily figure out the plot twists. This tension and second-guessing had always been a highlight in previous books however, and I was left feeling like something was missing from this book. Furthermore, I felt like the reason why Aldo went to Venice was a bit slim as I don't think Cosimo de Medici would have done such a thing as what he did in this book as that would have put so many people in danger and he was a careful, careful man. As usual though, the author is brilliant at bringing this time period to life and I really appreciated the descriptions of both Florence and Venice.

 

Just when I thought Aldo's character couldn't be developed anymore however, the author threw a new twist into this book and proved me wrong. I loved the return of one of Aldo's former lovers and the discussions surrounding that little happenstance as it was fascinating. All I will say about that is I'm glad Aldo finally got closure about that part of his life. 

 

Now, the contessa. One of my new favourite characters. Love it when a female character develops beautifully, is empowered, and has quite a character arc. She's charismatic, charming, beautiful, wealthy, connected, but deadly as a snake. And honestly, it's that deadly side that I love. I don't know how the author does it, but to make me feel sympathy and empathy for such a person just goes to show how brilliant the writing is. No, she can't be trusted, but she is a lot of fun to read about. 

 

Verdict

Carnival of Lies was a different entry to this series, but still fun to read. While I did have issues with some of the pacing and the tension in the story, it was still fast-paced with plenty of action and plenty of twists and turns. And the author has a way of transporting you to the time period so you feel like you are there. While not necessary, I do recommend you read the earlier entries in the series to get a better understanding of the recurring characters, some of the continuing storylines, and how they all connect. There were things that happened in this book that you would only have understood having read the earlier books and I think readers who only read this book will miss the nuances because they don't understand them. Highly recommend this series if you are looking for a good historical mystery with great description.  

 

 

 

Review: A Killer Motive by Hannah Mary McKinnon

A Killer Motive

by Hannah Mary McKinnon

Release Date: September 9, 2025

2025 MIRA

Ebook ARC; 400 Pages

ISBN: 978-0778387671

ASIN: B0DR5YGPGQ

Audiobook: B0DSLTR533

Genre: Fiction / Mystery / Thriller

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

4 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

To Stella Dixon, sneaking her teenage brother out of their parents’ house for a beach party was harmless fun—until Max disappeared without a trace.

Six years later, Stella’s family is still broken, and she can’t let go of her guilt. The only thing that keeps her going is helping other families find closure through A Killer Motive, her true crime podcast.

In a bid to find new sponsors and keep making episodes, Stella goes on a local radio show. But when she says on air that if she had just one clue, she’d find Max and bring whoever hurt him to justice, someone takes it as a challenge.

A mysterious invitation to play a game arrives, with the promise that if Stella wins, she’ll get information about what happened to Max. Stella thinks it’s a sick joke…until Max’s best friend vanishes. And she’s given new instructions: tell nobody or people will die.

My Thoughts

A Killer Motive was a fun book to read and I enjoyed it quite a bit. I was drawn into this book because of the high level of tension and suspense that just kept you turning the pages, plus I really liked the true crime podcast idea. I will admit that Stella's personality really grated on my nerves at the beginning with her demanding and entitled attitude, but she did grow on me somewhat as the story progressed. However, it was definitely the story itself that kept me engrossed, not the character development.

 

The plot itself was taughtly written with mention of criminality including thoughts behind why people may commit such crimes, nature versus nurture, behaviour disorders, mental and physical abuse, and countless other themes. All of these elements were blended into the story so you didn't feel like you were reading a psychology textbook. The tension builds quite steadily and things happen quickly so you barely have time to catch your breath before something else happens. Although not necessarily realistic, it does work well in this book and I just went along with it.  I did find the pacing somewhat uneven at the beginning of the book, but the tension more than made up for it and once the game commenced, I was hooked.  But I am a horror reader so I like that kind of thing. Bring it on! Best part of the book.

 

The book was definitely plot heavy, so I did feel like some of the character development fell flat. I wasn't overly crazy about Stella at the beginning as I thought she came across as entitled and demanding, especially when dealing about anything with regards to her brother. And the way she treated her hubby? Well, I wasn't sympathetic at all. Why can't two adults simply have a conversation about things in books? And honestly, I wasn't a fan of how the secondary characters were treated in this book to make Stella look like the better person. Everyone had secrets, including Stella, and I was often frustrated with her choices simply because they were so selfish. 

 

Verdict

A Killer Motive was interesting and the plot certainly moved along rather quickly with plenty of twists and turns. It was plot heavy which sacrificed the character development in my opinion and I wasn't impressed with how some of the characters were used for twists and turns. That being said, the game was fun and it was what kept me turning the pages and I really wished Stella had been pushed even further than what happened in the book as I think the author played it safe. I do recommend this book if you are looking for a twisty book that is compulsively readable and full of tension.  

 

Review: We Won't All Survive by Kate Alice Marshall

We Won't All Survive

by Kate Alice Marshall

Release Date: July 29, 2025

2025 Viking Books for Young Readers

Paperback ARC; 330 Pages

ISBN: 978-0593691830

ASIN: B0DLFQFF7H

Audiobook: B0DM6TTBSB

Genre: Fiction / YA / Mystery / Thriller

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

3 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

Two years ago Mercy Gray was hailed as a hero for saving lives during a mall shooting. She still carries souvenirs from that incident: the fragment of a bullet lodged in her back.

When billionaire-turned-TV-host Damien Dare recruits Mercy to compete on his new survivalist reality show, she can’t turn down a chance at the whopping cash prize that could send her sister to college—but when she and the other contestants arrive at the off-grid location, something isn’t right. The set is empty. The gates close without warning, trapping them inside. Then one of them turns up dead. What appeared at first to be a tragic accident quickly transforms as more contestants start dying. With time and resources running low, surviving this show takes on a new meaning.

 

My Thoughts

We Won't All Survive had a great premise and I definitely enjoyed the interactions of the characters as they realized something was seriously wrong and how they had to depend on each other knowing that one of them was possibly a murderer. The story moved along rather quickly with quite a few twists and turns, but I have to say, not too fond of that ending and definitely disliked the motive behind the whole thing.

 

Mercy was the main characters and I enjoyed her inner monologues as she was negotiating what to do and how to get things done when she realized they were stranded. Not someone who liked being in the limelight, she took charge simply because she didn't panic in difficult situations and the others started to consider her judgment as sound and good. As you learn more about her traumatic past, you can't help but feel empathy for what she is going through as she has trouble connecting with others and has trust issues. I liked being in her head and seeing her thoughts about what was happening. Having gone through my own traumas, I could understand a lot of what she was thinking and why she would be reluctant to trust people. I also liked how the author spent time on giving the other characters a voice as well so you did get a chance to learn more about the reasons why they were chosen.  

 

The plot had a dark theme running through it and I liked that the author didn't muddy the waters by adding too many other themes to the book. Using that theme and some of the underlying traumas experienced by the characters, the author managed to created quite an atmospheric book, one that was full of tension and twists and turns. The story moved along at a good pace and I don't think the tension really let up at all. And while I did suspect who the culprit was quite early, I did change my find a few times as I hit some twists and turns, only to come back to that person. What I didn't get was the motive. I don't necessarily have to have a motive in my books, but when there is one, it has to be believable, and this was not. The "issue with the show" thing, I got, and if the author had just left it there, it would have been fine, but to add this other element, nope, hokey as hell. And if this doesn't make sense, it will if you read the book. I don't want to give away spoilers. 

 

Verdict

We Won't All Survive was a fun, easy read that I enjoy, except for that ending. The plot moved along quite quickly, and the tension was kept at quite a good level which kept me flipping the pages. I loved the setting and the whole atmosphere of the story. I did think the main character was a highlight of this book and very well developed; it's just too bad that the whole reason for why they were there just wasn't believable for me. I do think it's worth reading just for the atmospheric setting though, and the author definitely has a way of pulling you into the story.  

 

Review: A Spell to Wake the Dead by Nicole Lesperance

A Spell to Wake the Dead

by Nicole Lesperance

Release Date: August 26, 2025

2025 G.P. Putnam's Sons Books for Young Readers

Ebook ARC; 352 Pages

ISBN: 978-0593856338

ASIN:  ‎ B0DP3NGGC7

Audiobook: B0DPJHVDR5

Genre: Fiction / YA / Horror

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

3.75 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

When Mazzy and her best friend Nora sneak down to the beach one moonlit night to cast a spell, they don’t expect to find a dead body. 

The girls know they should leave the investigation to the police, but they can’t shake the weird, supernatural connection they feel with the dead woman. Using spellwork and divination, they set out to find answers of their own. But after they uncover a rash of local disappearances stretching back years—and both girls start having occult visions and hearing ghostly, whispering voices—Mazzy worries that she and Nora are in danger.

Then, Nora finds a second body. And a whispering voice is telling her where to find more. With everything spiraling, Mazzy needs to figure out who to trust and how to sever this supernatural connection—or she and Nora might be the next bodies to wash up on the beach.

 

My Thoughts

A Spell to Wake the Dead drew me in as I was interested in how far someone would go if they actually found a dead body in this scenario. I mean, no one goes to the beach expecting a dead body to roll in with the tide, but having read a multitude of books whereby this happens, I often wondered how I would react in a similar situation. And how would Mazzy and Nora explain why they were on the beach in the first place? How do you explain to the police you were practicing witchcraft at midnight? It was a pretty interesting way to set up the vibe of the book and include some spooky atmosphere though.  

 

In all fairness, I was actually quite surprised at how deeply the book delved into witchcraft and how the girls were using spellcraft in their daily lives. It definitely reflects the amount of research the author must have done and it shows in how the subject was treated in this book. The author took the time to not only have her characters make some serious mistakes because they didn't have experience, but also delved into topics such as tarot card reading, cults, darker forces, abuse of power, and the use of natural elements found in our world. I liked how it was approached as natural, but also showcased how the girls were treated by others because they didn't understand what they were doing. Personally, I would have liked an even deeper exploration of the topics than what we got in the book as it was fascinating.

 

The plot itself was interesting, but I did find it a bit uneven at times. Because the book was so focused on the happenings and the doings, little room was left for character development and this was problematic because I wanted to empathize with Mazzy's choices, but I just couldn't. While the book showcased how out of their element the girls were and how dangerous the forces were with which they were playing, they still made some stupid choices and continued what they were doing. Yes, they tried to consult an adult, but some of the other choices just made me grit my teeth.  I didn't necessarily mind the rapid pace of the book, but it certainly didn't help when it came time to connecting with the characters. Honestly, when something startling or shocking did occur, I wasn't emotionally invested in what was happening to the characters and felt distant to what was happening. There were a lot of twists and turns and some dark elements to the story, so I should have felt more strongly over what the characters were experiencing than what I did. 

 

Verdict

A Spell to Wake the Dead was a decent read and I did enjoy it quite a bit, enough to pretty much finish it in one sitting. While I enjoyed the twists and turns, some of which caught me off guard, I did feel like this was far more plot-driven which compromised a lot of the character development. I do think there is a lot to explore in this book with regards to thematic elements as well. However, I wasn't overly crazy about the ending as I think there should have been far more consequences for the girls than there were as they were playing with forces they didn't understand and I don't think the danger of it all was fully stressed in the ending. Anyhow, this was a fun ride, but I did think the substance of the book was somewhat lacking and did feel a bit let down at the end.  

 

Review: One Dark Night by Hannah Richell

One Dark Night

by Hannah Richell

Release Date: August 19, 2025

2025 Atria Books

Ebook ARC; 384 Pages

ISBN: 978-1668081334

ASIN:  ‎ B0DJJYSWWL

Audiobook: B0DWYC2CB3

Genre: Fiction / Mystery / Halloween

Source: Review copy from publisher

 

4 / 5 Stars

 

Summary

On Halloween, a group of teenage students meet in the woods near Sally in the Wood, a road steeped in local lore and rumored to be haunted by the ghost of a murdered girl. By the end of the night, one student will be dead.

Rachel, the school guidance counselor, is trying to keep a handle on her increasingly distant teenaged daughter, Ellie, while students and parents panic and mourn. Her ex-husband and detective Ben, dealing with a personal crisis of his own, has concerns about his daughter’s safety as he investigates the death of one of her classmates. Meanwhile, Ellie is keeping secrets from both her parents, including one about where she was that night.

 

My Thoughts

One Dark Night is one of those books I opted to read because it was about Halloween, and there is something I just love about the creepiness of that time, so here we are. However, I was pleasantly surprised at how effective the atmosphere of the book was with relation to the mystery; the woods, the creepy legend, the secrets with the community, and the general atmosphere certainly led to a menacing tale that was right up my alley, and I stayed up way too late finishing this book.

 

For me, the most impressive thing about this book was the setting. I adored the descriptions of the surrounding area and thought the folly was the perfect setting for such a book. As a teenager, I would have loved exploring the ruins left there and I would have definitely been fascinated by the legend; if you had asked me to go up there at night to go exploring, I would have been all over it. The whole thing had gothic undertones that permeated the whole book and considering the private school was set right beside the woods leading to the folly, you can guess what kinds of trouble teenagers would get themselves into, especially when told it was forbidden or out of bounds.  

 

The plot itself moved along at a good pace and it certainly delivered when it came to twists and turns. Typically I can pick out the culprit in a book such as this, but this book caught me off guard and I missed the mark, so I was pleasantly surprised by that. The murder itself was complex and multi-layered, something that gave me a lot to think about when the book finished as there were a lot of themes running through the story, themes of loyalty, family, neglect, deception, gaslighting, secrets, friendship, mental illness, and self-reflection. I liked how many of the characters were flawed and because of this, made mistakes when it came to judging what happened as well as judging the people in their lives. Some difficult realizations come to people as they realized what was actually going on their lives was not as rosy as it appeared and they had blinders on because they didn't want to see/acknowledge what was in front of them.  I think the only frustrating thing about a book like this is you don't really know if the characters have learned from their mistakes or if they will continue down the same paths that led them there in the first place.

 

Verdict

One Dark Night was a very well crafted mystery and it certainly delivered when it came to twists and turns. I thought the characters were interesting, even if some of the character development was a bit one-dimensional. The atmosphere had a spooky element to it and the author did a great job at including many credible suspects so you had to piece together what was happening with the main characters. Overall, I thought the book was fun and enjoyed it quite a bit. Highly recommend to anyone who likes a good mystery with atmosphere.